One of the most talked-about musical moments of the summer is JoJo Siwa's recent rendition of the 1981 classic "Bette Davis Eyes." On July 11, she shared her retro-style rendition, sparking intense online reactions. The song's original singer, Kim Carnes, even responded nuancedly.

‍

The Controversy Unfolded

JoJo Siwa's studio version of "Bette Davis Eyes," which has a throwback Hollywood vibe, was released on July 11. Wearing a cropped blonde wig and a gingham gown, she captioned the photo, "'Bette Davis Eyes' cover out now, stream everywhere you listen to music." Inspired by her electrifying live performance in London, she presented it as a celebration of confidence and mystery.

But the response was swift, and mostly harsh. Her autotune use, raspy voice, and general quality were criticized by many listeners. While one commenter criticized her for deviating from her signature ponytail, another said it sounded like an "anti-smoking campaign."

Then Kim Carnes replied. She hinted at displeasure in a now-deleted TikTok tweet, stating, “There is a difference between singing a song... and embodying it... authenticity is what makes music timeless.”

Later, in the American news outlet,TMZ, she stated:

“The phrasing, the tone, even the little inflections; it all felt a bit too close.” She also stressed that personal attacks are unacceptable, even while asserting her right to speak about how closely Siwa’s version resembled.

‍

The Fallout Online

The moment ignited a heated debate. On Reddit, one user said:

“Kim didn’t write the song; but she made it famous. She has a claim.” Another wondered aloud why fans obsess over JoJo so much.

Meanwhile, commentary writers labeled the release “bold” yet cringe-worthy, noting the shift in Siwa’s image and sound.

This isn't just a cover; it's a component of a larger rebranding, in between her new song "Raspy," (a self-aware clapback to her critics)s, and her evolving appearance.

‍

Why does it all matter?

Musical covers must strike a balance between authenticity and tribute. If they sound too close, they risk being perceived as blatant imitation, but if they sound too different, they risk offending listeners of the original song.

Reinvention vs Legacy Legacy performers, such as Kim Carnes, who is well known for her 1981 hit song "Bette Davis Eyes," have a particular sound that defines their personal brand. A cover that is too similar to that style may elicit strong, emotional responses.

Internet Culture Clash: A real-time generational and stylistic clash is taking place on social media as JoJo Siwa's online, meme-literate fanbase and Carnes' classic pop legacy collide.

‍

Final Take

JoJo Siwa's cover of "Bette Davis Eyes" was more than simply another release. It was a cultural moment, nostalgic galore, and generational musical differences. Kim Carnes' measured response and fan backlash demonstrate how deeply personal a musical legacy can be and how quickly it may become viral.

‍